PVG vs DBS: which criminal record check do you need?
How Scotland's PVG Scheme, Level 1 and Level 2 disclosures compare with DBS and AccessNI checks, and how to choose the right one for a role.
In short: the check follows where the job is based. Scotland uses Disclosure Scotland (PVG, Level 1 and Level 2). England and Wales use the DBS. Northern Ireland uses AccessNI. For regulated work with children or protected adults in Scotland, the person must be a PVG Scheme member.
The four UK disclosure systems
| Where the role is | Who issues checks | Main check types |
|---|---|---|
| Scotland | Disclosure Scotland | PVG Scheme membership and record, Level 1, Level 2 |
| England and Wales | Disclosure and Barring Service (DBS) | Basic, Standard, Enhanced, Enhanced with barred lists |
| Northern Ireland | AccessNI | Basic, Standard, Enhanced (with barred lists where eligible) |
What changed in Scotland in 2025
The Disclosure (Scotland) Act 2020 came into force on 1 April 2025. PVG Scheme membership became mandatory for people doing regulated work with children or protected adults, and the old Basic, Standard and Enhanced disclosures were replaced with Level 1 and Level 2 disclosures. Organisations that countersign applications are now called accredited bodies.
PVG compared with an Enhanced DBS
- Purpose: both are used for work with children and vulnerable or protected adults.
- Monitoring: PVG membership includes continuous monitoring by Disclosure Scotland. A DBS certificate is a snapshot, unless the candidate subscribes to the DBS Update Service.
- Barring: PVG shows whether someone is barred from the children's or adults' workforce in Scotland; an Enhanced DBS with barred lists does the same in England and Wales.
- Portability: a PVG member moving employer still needs a current scheme record for the new role; a DBS Update Service subscriber can have their status checked online.
Choosing the right check
- Where is the role based? That decides the disclosure service.
- Is it regulated work (Scotland) or regulated activity (England and Wales)? If yes, PVG or Enhanced DBS with barred lists.
- If not, is the role eligible for a higher-level check under the legislation? If yes, Level 2 (Scotland) or Standard/Enhanced (DBS).
- Otherwise, a Level 1 (Scotland) or Basic DBS check.
Related checks: PVG Scheme membership, Enhanced DBS with barred lists, AccessNI checks.
This guide is general information, not legal advice. Rules change, so check current official guidance or ask us about a specific role.
Ready to screen with confidence?
Tell us about your roles and we will recommend the right checks for each one, with a clear quote.
International recruits
Care homes & social care