Being screened? Candidate help Compliance Contact
Guide

PVG vs DBS: which criminal record check do you need?

How Scotland's PVG Scheme, Level 1 and Level 2 disclosures compare with DBS and AccessNI checks, and how to choose the right one for a role.

Updated 15 November 2026By the Highland Bureau team

In short: the check follows where the job is based. Scotland uses Disclosure Scotland (PVG, Level 1 and Level 2). England and Wales use the DBS. Northern Ireland uses AccessNI. For regulated work with children or protected adults in Scotland, the person must be a PVG Scheme member.

The four UK disclosure systems

Where the role isWho issues checksMain check types
ScotlandDisclosure ScotlandPVG Scheme membership and record, Level 1, Level 2
England and WalesDisclosure and Barring Service (DBS)Basic, Standard, Enhanced, Enhanced with barred lists
Northern IrelandAccessNIBasic, Standard, Enhanced (with barred lists where eligible)

What changed in Scotland in 2025

The Disclosure (Scotland) Act 2020 came into force on 1 April 2025. PVG Scheme membership became mandatory for people doing regulated work with children or protected adults, and the old Basic, Standard and Enhanced disclosures were replaced with Level 1 and Level 2 disclosures. Organisations that countersign applications are now called accredited bodies.

PVG compared with an Enhanced DBS

  • Purpose: both are used for work with children and vulnerable or protected adults.
  • Monitoring: PVG membership includes continuous monitoring by Disclosure Scotland. A DBS certificate is a snapshot, unless the candidate subscribes to the DBS Update Service.
  • Barring: PVG shows whether someone is barred from the children's or adults' workforce in Scotland; an Enhanced DBS with barred lists does the same in England and Wales.
  • Portability: a PVG member moving employer still needs a current scheme record for the new role; a DBS Update Service subscriber can have their status checked online.

Choosing the right check

  1. Where is the role based? That decides the disclosure service.
  2. Is it regulated work (Scotland) or regulated activity (England and Wales)? If yes, PVG or Enhanced DBS with barred lists.
  3. If not, is the role eligible for a higher-level check under the legislation? If yes, Level 2 (Scotland) or Standard/Enhanced (DBS).
  4. Otherwise, a Level 1 (Scotland) or Basic DBS check.

Related checks: PVG Scheme membership, Enhanced DBS with barred lists, AccessNI checks.

This guide is general information, not legal advice. Rules change, so check current official guidance or ask us about a specific role.

Talk to us

Ready to screen with confidence?

Tell us about your roles and we will recommend the right checks for each one, with a clear quote.